Le but de l'article est d'établir des relations entre, d'une part, la caractérisation générale kuhnienne de l'incommensurabilité comme impossibilité de traduire l'une dans l'autre les taxinomies de théories scientifiques rivales et, d'autre part, la version plus spécifique de l'incommensurabilité proposée par Hacking, laquelle porte sur des théories concurrentes s'étant stabilisées en relation à des équipements de laboratoire et des techniques de mesure différents. Sur la base d'une analyse, inspirée des travaux de Duhem, de la nature des taxinomies scientifiques, on soutiendra que l'approche linguistique kuhnienne est inadéquate pour rendre compte de la manière dont les termes scientifiques s'appliquent à la nature dans le domaine des sciences de laboratoire, au sein desquelles le rôle des opérations de mesure est essentiel. L'analyse introduira la notion de taxinomie duale et celle de caractère ostensif d'une théorie. Il apparaîtra que, une fois ces deux notions prises en compte, il devient possible de poser les bases d'une version taxinomique élargie de l'incommensurabilité, susceptible de fournir un cadre commun pour la discussion des exemples introduits par Kuhn et Hacking.
The aim of the article is to establish relations between Kuhn's general characterization of incommensurability as the impossibility to translate the taxonomies pertaining to rival scientific theories into one another and Hacking's more specific version of incommensurability affecting competing theories that have stabilized relatively to different laboratory equipments and measurement techniques. On the basis of an analysis of the nature of scientific taxonomies that takes its inspiration from the works of Duhem, it will be argued that Kuhn's language-based approach is inadequate to provide an account of the way scientific terms apply to nature in the domain of physical laboratory science, in which the role of measurement procedures is essential. The analysis will be carried out by introducing the notion of dual taxonomy and the notion of ostensive character of a theory. It will result that, once these two notions are taken into account, it becomes possible to lay the foundations of an enlarged taxonomic version of incommensurability which can provide a common framework for the discussion of the examples introduced by Kuhn and Hacking.
@article{PHSC_2004__8_1_235_0, author = {Trizio, Emiliano}, title = {Incommensurability and laboratory science}, journal = {Philosophia Scientiae}, volume = {8}, year = {2004}, pages = {235-267}, language = {en}, url = {http://dml.mathdoc.fr/item/PHSC_2004__8_1_235_0} }
Trizio, Emiliano. Incommensurability and laboratory science. Philosophia Scientiae, Tome 8 (2004) pp. 235-267. http://gdmltest.u-ga.fr/item/PHSC_2004__8_1_235_0/
[1] Possible Worlds in Humanities, Arts and Sciences: Proceedings of Nobel Symposium 65, Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. 1983: PSA 1982: Proceedings of the 1982 Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, vol. 2. East Lansing, MI: Philosophy of Science Association, | MR 988911
(editor) 1989.-[2] Intellectual Autobiography, in P. A. Schilpp (editor), The Philosophy of Rudolf Carnap, Lasalle, IL: Open Court.
1963.-[3] How We Relate Theory to Observation
1993.-[4] Substanzbegriff und Funktionsbegriff, Berlin: Bruno Cassirer Verlag.
1910.-[5] La théorie Physique : son objet, sa structure, Paris : Vrin. English translation by P. P. Wiener, 1991, The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory, Princeton: Princeton University Press. | MR 1145487 | Zbl 0058.17503
1906.-[6] PSA 1990: Proceedings of the 1990 Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, volume 2, East Lansing, MI: Philosophy of Science Association.
, and (editors) 1991.-[7] Representing and intervening, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1983.-[8] The Self-Vindication of the Laboratory Sciences
1992.-[9] Working in a New World: The Taxonomic Solution
1993.-[10] L'importance de la classification chez le dernier Kuhn, Archives de Philosophie, 66(3) : 389-402.
2003.-[11] The Interpretative Turn: Philosophy, Science, Culture, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
, and (editors) 1991.-[12] World Changes, Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press. | MR 1222714
(editor) 1993.-[13] Die Wissenschaftsphilosophie Thomas S. Kuhns: Rekonstruktion und Grundlagenprobleme. Braunschweig: Vieweg. English translation by A. T. Levine, 1993, Reconstructing Scientific Revolutions, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. The pages mentioned in the paper are the ones of the English edition.
1989.-[14] Logische Untersuchungen, Hamburg: Felix Meiner Verlag.
1992.-[15] The function of Measurement in Modern Physical Science, Isis 52: 161-193. Reprinted in [Kuhn 1977, 178-224. The pages mentioned in the paper are the ones of this last book.
1961.-[16] Reflections on My Critics
1970a.-[17] The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
1970b.-[18] Second Thoughts on Paradigms, in F. Suppe, ed., The Structure of Scientific Theories. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 459-482. Reprinted in [Kuhn 1977, 293-319. The pages mentioned in the paper are the ones of this last book. | MR 392268
1974.-[19] The Essential Tension, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
1977.-[20] Commensurability, Comparability, Communicability | MR 1891737
1983.-[21] Possible Worlds in History of Science
1989.-[22] The Road since Structure
1991a.-[23] The Natural and the Human Sciences
1991b.-[24] Afterwords
1993.-[25] The Road Since Structure. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
2000.-[26] Lakatos, Imre and Musgrave allan (editors) 1970.- Criticism and Growth of Knowledge: Proceedings of the International Colloquium in the Philosophy of Science, London 1965, volume 4, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. | MR 403864
[27] L'empirismo logico, Roma: Carocci editore.
2002.-[28] Constructing Quarks, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
1984.-[29] The Mangle of Practice, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. | Zbl 0834.01019
1995.-[30] Science as practice and culture, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
(editor) 1992.-[31] De la commune mesure phénoménale entre théories physiques dites incommensurables, Philosophia Scientiae, 7(2) : 239-265.
2003.-[32] The Structure of Scientific Theories, Urbana: University of Illinois Press. | MR 392268
(editor) 1974.-