The notion of randomness from Aristotle to Poincaré

Sheynin, O. B.

Mathématiques et Sciences humaines, Tome 116 (1991), p. 41-55 / Harvested from Numdam

Résumé

Aristote et même des philosophes et scientifiques plus anciens ont essayé de définir le concept de hasard. L'auteur décrit, depuis Aristote jusqu'à Poincaré, diverses tentatives de formalisation du hasard dans le domaine des mathématiques. Il insiste sur les interprétations du hasard qui ont été proposées dans les sciences de la nature et en philosophie, puis sur les relations entre le hasard et la nécessité.

Abstract

Aristotle and even earlier scientist and philosophers attempted to define, or at least to through light upon randomness. The author sketches the attempts to direct concept of randomness into the realm of mathematical science from Aristotle up to Poincaré. He dwells on the various interpretations of randomness that were pronounced in natural science and philosophy, and on the interrelation between necessity and randomness.

Détail

Publié le : 1991-01-01

MR 1116944 | Zbl 0755.01005

Bibliographie

[1] Laws of Manu, Oxford, 1886, (Sacred book of the East, Vol.25).

[2] Chirikov, B.V., "The nature of the statistical laws of classical mechanics", in : Methodological and philosophical problems of physics, Novosibirsk, 1982, 181-196. In Russian. [Metodologich i filosofsk. problemy fiziki] -

[3] Sheynin, O.B., "On the prehistory of the theory of probability ", Arch. hist. ex. sci., Vol. 12, n°2,1974,97-141. | MR 497468 | Zbl 0284.01002

[4] Nalimov,V.V., The language of stochastic concepts, Moscow, 1976, in Russian. [Yazyk veroiatnostnykh predstavlenii]

[5] Junkersfeld, J., The Aristotelian-Thomistic concept of chance, Notre Dame, Indiana, 1945.

[6] Kendall, M.G., "The beginnings of a probability calculus", Biometrika, Vol.43, n°1-2,1956,1-14. | MR 76678 | Zbl 0070.36101

[7] Sambursky, S., "On the possible and probable in ancient Greece", Osiris, Vol.12, 1956, 35-48. | Zbl 0071.24301

[8] David, F.N., Games, gods and gambling, London, 1962. | Zbl 0117.24603

[9] Byrne, E.F., Probability and opinion, The Hague, 1968.

[10] Rabinovitch, N.L., Probability and statistical inference in ancient and medieval Jewish literature, Toronto, 1973. | Zbl 0272.01001

[11] Gnedenko, B.V., From the history of the science of the random, Moscow,1981, in Russian. [Iz istorii nauki o sluchainom].

[12] Sheynin, O.B., "Newton and the classical theory of probability ", Arch. hist. ex. sci., Vol.7, n°3, 1971,217-243. | Zbl 0236.01004

[13] Sheynin, O.B., J.H., "Lambert's work in probability", Ibid., 244-256. | Zbl 0263.01017

[14] Cournot, A.A., Essai sur les fondements de nos connaissances, t. 1. Paris 1851.

[15] Chuprov, A.A., Essays on the theory of statistics (1909), Moscow, 1959, in Russian [Ocherkipo teorii statiski].

[15] Poisson, S.D., Recherches sur la probabilité des jugements etc., Paris,1837.

[17] Von Mises, R., "Grundlagen der Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung (1919)", Sel. papers, Vol.2, Providence, Rhode Island, 1964, 57-105. | JFM 47.0483.01

[18] Von Mises, R., Wahrscheinlichkeit, Statistik und Wahrheit. (1928, 1936, 1951), Engl. transl. : London, 1939; New York - London, 1964. | JFM 54.0540.12

[19] Church, A., "On the concept of a random sequence", Bull. Amer. Math. Soc., Vol.46, n°2,1940,130-135. | JFM 66.0601.01 | MR 911 | Zbl 0022.36904

[20] Uspensky, V.A., Semenov, A.L., The theory of algorithms : main discoveries and applications, Moscow, 1987, in Russian. [Teoria algoritmov etc.]. | Zbl 0632.68037

[21] Kolmogorov, A.N., Uspensky, V.A., "Algorithms and randomness", in Russian [Teoria veroiatnostei i ee prim], Vol.32, n°3,1987, 425-455. | MR 914935 | Zbl 0627.60006

[22] Bentley, R., "Sermons (1693)", in Newton, I., Papers and letters on natural philosophy, Cambridge,1958.

[23] Lamarck, J.B., "Aperçu analytique des connaissances humaines ", (MS, 1810-1814), in Vachon, M. et al., Inédits de Lamarck, Paris, 1972, 69-141.

[24] Lamarck, J.B., Histoire naturelle des animaux sans vertèbres, t.I, Paris, 1815.

[25] Kepler, J., "De stella nova (1606)", French transl. of a passage in : Servien, P., Science et hasard, Paris, 1952, p.132.

[26] Laplace, P.S., "Recherches sur l'intégration des équations différentielles (1776)", Œuvr. compl., t.8, Paris, 1891, 69-197.

[27] Darwin, C., Origin of species (1859), London-New York, 1958.

[28] Newton, I., Optics (1704), Opera, Vol.4. London,1782,1-264.

[29] Newton, I., Theological manuscripts, Liverpool, 1950.

[30] Lamarck, J.B., "Espèce", Nouv. dict. hist. natur., t.10,1817, 441-451.

[31] Sheynin, O.B., "On the history of the statistical method in physics", Arch. Hist. Ex. Sci., Vol.33, n°4, 1985, 351-382. | MR 802299 | Zbl 0571.01020

[32] Aristotle, Metaphysica.Works, Vol.8, Oxford.

[33] Aquinas, Thomas, Summa theologica, Engl. transl. : Great books of the Western world, Vols.19-20. Chicago, 1952.

[34] Mahalanobis, P.C., "The foundations of statistics", Sankhya, Ind. J. Stat., Vol.18; n°1-2, 1957, 183-194. | Zbl 0081.00503

[35] Darwin, C., The variation of animals and plants under domestication, Vols1-2, London, 1885

[36] Herschel, W., "Astronomical observations and experiments etc. (1817)", Scient. papers, Vol.2, London, 1912, 575-591. | JFM 43.0021.01

[37] Struve, F.G.W., Études d'astronomie stellaire, St Petersbourg,1847.

[38] Maxwell, J.C., "Discourse on molecules (MS,1873)", in : Campbell, L. & Garnett, W., Life of Maxwell (1882), London,1884, 272-274.

[39] Hegel, G.W.F., Wissenschaft der Logik, T.1. 1 (1812), Hamburg, 1978.

[40] Aristotle, Physica.Works, Vol.2.

[41] Aristotle, De generatione animalum. Works, Vol.5.

[42] Kepler, J., Neue Astronomie(1609, in Latin), München- Berlin, 1929. | JFM 55.0603.01

[43] Kepler, J., Epitome of Copernican astronomy, book 4 (1620, in Latin), in Great books of the Western World, Vol. 16, Chicago,1952, 845-1004 (books 4 and 5).

[44] Kepler, J., Welt-Harmonik (1619, in Latin), München- Berlin, 1939. | Zbl 0022.09901

[45] Kant, I., Allgemeine Naturgeschichte und Theorie des Himmels (1755), Werke, Bd 1, Berlin, 1910, 215-368.

[46] Adanson, M., "Examen de la question si les espèces changent parmi les plantes", Hist. Acad. Roy, Paris avec Mém. math. et phys., 1769 (1772) ; Mém., 31-48.

[47] Lamarck, J.B., Annuaire météorologique [t.1], Paris, pour l'an 8 (1800).

[48] Sheynin, O.B., "On the history of the statistical method in meteorology", Arch. Hist. Ex. Sci., Vol.31, n°1, 1984, 53-95. | MR 769540 | Zbl 0553.01002

[49] Humboldt, A., "Des lignes isothermes", Mém. Phys. Chim. Soc. d'Arcueil, t.3, 1817, 462-602.

[50] Humboldt, A., Fragmens de géologie et de climatologie asiatiques, t.2. Paris,1831.

[51] Körber, H.G., "Über Humboldts Arbeiten zur Meteorologie und Klimatologie", in : Humboldt, Gedenkschrift, Berlin, 1959, 289-335.

[52] Moivre(De), A., A method of approximating the sum of the terms of the binomial (a+b)n etc.(1733, in Latin), [53, 1756, 243-254].

[53] Moivre(De), A., Doctrine of chances (1718,1738,1756), New York, 1967.

[54] Belvalkar, S.K., Ranade, R.D., History of Indian philosophy, Vol.2. Poona, 1927.

[55] Cournot, A.A., Exposition de la théorie des chances et des probabilités (1843), Paris, 1984, ed. B.Bru. | MR 768180

[56] Cioffari, V., Fortune and fate from Democritus to St Thomas Aquinas, New York, 1935.

[57] Hobbes, T., Of liberty and necessity (1646), Engl. works, Vol.4, London, 1840, 229-278.

[58] Darwin, C., More letters, Vol. 1, London, 1903.

[59] Alembert(D'), L, J., " Doutes et questions sur le calcul des probabilités", in author's Mélanges de littérature, d'hist. et de philos., t.5, Amsterdam, 1768, 239-264.

[60] Laplace, P.S., Essai philosophique sur les probabilités (1814). Œuvr. compl., t.7, n° 1, Paris, 1886, separate paging.

[61] Aristotle, De Caelo, Works, Vol.2.

[62] Kepler, J., Bericht vom neuen Stern. Ges. Werke, Bd 1., München, 1938, 391-399.

[63] La Placette, J., Traité des jeux de hasardI, La Haye,1714.

[64] Arbuthnot, J., "An argument for divine Providence etc (1712)", in : Studies in the history of statistics and prob., Vol.2, London, 1977, 30-34.

[65] Boyle, R., "Some considerations touching the usefulness of experimental natural philosophy (1663-1671)", Works, Vol.2, London, 1772, 36-49.

[66] Arnault, A., Nicole, P., Logique de Port-Royal (1662), Paris, 1877.

[67] Voltaire, Homélies, Première homélie (1767), Œuvr. compl., t.26, Paris, 1879, 315-354.

[68] Bernoulli, D., "Recherches physiques et astronomiques etc ", in Pièces qui ont remporté le prix de l'Acad. Roy. Sci. en 1734, Paris, 1735, 95-122.

[69] Laplace, P.S., "Mémoire sur l'inclinaison moyenne descomètes (1776)", Œuvr. compl., t.8, 1891, 279-321.

[70] Maupertuis, P.L.M., Venus physique (1745), Oeuvr., t.2. Lyon, 1756,1-133.

[71] Maupertuis, P.L.M., Système de la nature (1751), Ibid., 135-184.

[72] Herschel, J.F., "Sun (lecture, 1861)", in author's Familiar lectures on scient. subjects, London- New York, 1866, 47-90.

[73] Baer, K., Zum Streit über den Darwinismus, Dorpat, 1873.

[74] Boole, G., "On the theory of probabilities (1851)", in author's Studies in logic and probability, London, 1952, 247-259.

[75] Newcomb, S., On the position of the Galactic, Carnegie Instn. of Washington, 1904, n°10.

[76] Forbes, J.D., "On the alleged evidence for a physical connection between stars", Phil. Mag., Vol.35,1849, 132-133; Vol.37, 1850, 401-427.

[77] Kapteyn, J.C., "Statistical methods in stellar astronomy", [Repts] Intern. congr. arts and sci. St Louis-Boston, 1904, N.p., 1906, Vol.4, 396-425.

[78] Struve, F.G.W., "Review of Struve, O., Bestimmung der Constante der Praecession. Petersburg, 1842", Bull. scient. Acad. Imp. Sci. St. Pétersb., t.10, n°9 (225), 1842, 129-139.

[79] Boltzmann, L., "Über das Wärmegleichgewicht (1871)", Wiss. Abh., Bd. 1. Leipzig, 1909, 237-258.

[80] Boltzmann, L., "Weitere Studien über das Wärmegleichgewicht (1872)", Ibid., 316-402.

[81] Hume, D., Treatise on human nature, Vols.1-2 (1739), London, 1874.

[82] Holbach(D'), P.H.T., Système de la nature, pt.2, Paris,1781.

[83] Laplace, P.S., Théorie analytique des probabilités (1812), Œuvr. compl., t.7, Paris, 1886.

[84] Todhunter, I., A history of the mathematical theory of probability (1865), New York, 1965.

[85] Darwin, C., The formation of vegetable mould etc., (1881), London, 1945.

[86] Bertrand, J., Calcul des probabilités (1888), New York, 1972. | Zbl 0325.60001

[87] Galen, C., De sanitata tuenda. Engl. transl. : Hygiene, Springfield, Illinois,1951.

[88] Maxwell, J.C., Does the progress of physical science tend to give any advantage to the opinion of necessity etc., (Read 1873), In Campbell, L. et al [38], 357-366.

[89] Maxwell, J.C., On the stability of the motion of Saturn's rings (1859), Scient. papers, Vol.1 (1890), Paris, 1927, 288-376.

[90] Von Kries, J., Die Principien der Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung, Freiburg i.B.,1886 (reprint: Tübingen, 1927).

[91] Von Plato, J., "Instability and the accumulation of small effects", in Probability and conceptual change in scient. thought, eds, M. Heidelberger & L. Krüger, Bielefeld, 1982, 77-93.

[92] Pirogov, N.N., "Uber das Gesetz Boltzmann's", Repertorium Phys., Bd.27, 1891, 515-546. | JFM 23.1196.02

[93] Leibniz, G.W., Allgemeine Untersuchungen über die Analyse der Begriffe und wahren Sätze (MS, 1686), in author's Fragmente zur Logik, Berlin, 1960, 241-303.

[94] Maxwell, J.C., "Illustrations of the dynamical theory of gases (1860)", Scient. papers, Vol.1, 377-410.

[95] Maxwell, J.C., "On the dynamical evidence of the molecular constitution of bodies (1875)", Scient. papers, Vol.2 (1890), Paris, 1927, 418-438.

[96] Laplace, P.S., "Exposition du système du monde", Œuvr. compl., t.6. Paris, 1884 (reprint of the 1835 ed.).

[97] Kant, I., Kritik der reinen Vernunft (1781), Werke, Bd.3, Berlin,1911.

[98] Engels, F., Dialektik der Natur, written 1873-1882, first publ.1925, Berlin, 1971.

[99] Poincare, H., Calcul des probabilités, Paris, 1896 et 1912, The second ed. was reprinted in 1923. The Introduction to this edition is a reprint of the article "Le hasard ", La Rev. du Mois, t.3, 1907, 257-276.

[100] Pearson, K., A. de Moivre, Nature, Vol.117, n°2946, 1926, 551-552.

[101] Pearson, K., The history of statistics in the 17th and 18th centuries, lectures 1921-1933, ed. E.S. Pearson, London a.o., 1978. | Zbl 0439.01006